2nd one wont show for me.
1st one is 6.8/10
I like it, and for your 1st sig, its very good, but there is a lot missing. Such as content/creativity/boarder ect... But like I said, for your 1st attempt, its VERY good.
I see potential, alot more potential then most beginners.
Your text is great for a first, the colors match.
7/10 on a beginners scale.
If you need any help feel free to PM me.